WatchSonoma Watch

Sebastopol considers opposing county fluoridation plan


Sebastopol city officials, who oversee an independent municipal water system, are likely to take a stand Tuesday on a highly controversial county proposal to fluoridate the drinking water supply outside the city.

In so doing, they’d be following the lead of the Cotati City Council, which last fall submitted a letter to Sonoma County supervisors opposing the plan. Cotati officials said they favored expanding dental services and education for those at risk of tooth decay.

But while Cotati is among the nine contractors whose water supply would contain fluoride if county supervisors opted to pursue the plan, Sebastopol is not.

Some City Council members, however, say their constituents roam far and wide around Sonoma County to communities “where they would have no choice in their consumption of fluoride.”

Council members also expressed concern about the cost of removing fluoride from wastewater treated at the regional plant and the potential risk to wildlife in the Laguna de Santa Rosa should fluoride-tainted wastewater find its way there.

Fluoride may also seep into the groundwater that feeds Sebastopol’s wells, said Mayor Robert Jacob.

“We know that there’s conflicting science and conflicting opinions on fluoridation,” Jacob said. “But for us to add something that we don’t have definitive data that it is safe is a wrong measure.”

Councilmembers Michael Kyes and Sarah Glade Gurney, who serve on the council’s water subcommittee, recommended the city take a position against fluoridation.

“We’re just agreeing with Cotati’s decision that people should have a choice whether they have fluoride in their water or not,” Kyes said.

Sonoma County officials are contemplating adding fluoride to the public water supply to combat an epidemic of tooth decay, a practice that has the support of the U.S. Surgeon General’s Office, the World Health Organization and the American Dental Association, which called it “the single most effective public health measure to prevent dental decay.”

The Centers for Disease Control touts community water fluoridation as “one of 10 great public health achievements of the 20th century.” It says 75 percent of all American community water systems receive fluoride in their water.

It will be fall “at the soonest” before county supervisors consider following suit, thanks to ongoing financial and engineering studies authorized by the Board of Supervisors last year, Assistant County Health Director Tammy Moss Chandler said.

The county is preparing to award a contract for some aquatics studies based on Sonoma County waterways, though officials downplayed concerns about environmental pollution from fluoridated drinking water.

“The preponderance of evidence suggests that fluoridation will not endanger fish, wildlife or water supplies,” Chandler said.

The county project would have an estimated cost of $8.5 million, with annual upkeep of nearly $1 million, according to preliminary estimates released a year ago.

An impassioned network of opponents are resisting the plan, include some who contend that fluoride puts human health at risk.

“The question is,” said Jacob, “do you do something that’s unclear, or do you hold off to maintain the status quo and ensure current levels of safety?”

3 Responses to “Sebastopol considers opposing county fluoridation plan”

  1. And what a shame, Nancy, that the precious time that you have spent “dissing” the Sebastopol City Council for taking a brave and correct stand against this outdated, expensive, ineffective and dangerous “public health” practice could have been spent doing some research with an open mind which would have revealed this practice from the dark ages of medicine for what it truly is: a failure of the grandest proportions. If you want to be fluoridated, then that certainly is your right. But do it on your own time and your own dime – and leave this toxic waste – hydrofluorosilicic acid, a.k.a. industrial-grade “fluoride” – out of our precious Sonoma County water supply.

    Thumb up 5 Thumb down 3

  2. James Bennett says:

    You mean they don’t want to drink industrial waste neurotoxin?

    They don’t think it should be in the County’s water table?

    Transpirating through their skin, inhaling it as gas during a hot shower?

    Those wacked out West County hippies.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. Nancy says:

    As my captain used to say, “seldom right but never in doubt.” That motto should be engraved on the Sebastopol city hall.

    The flat earth people in the stoned city could spend years on the couch talking about their narcissistic, neurotic selves.

    Tooth decay is more important to them than good hygiene. What a shame for the children living in that modern hippie commune.

    Thumb up 4 Thumb down 7

Leave a Reply