WatchSonoma Watch

Healdsburg group wants hotel crackdown


Healdsburg residents are girding for another growth fight, this time over a potential hotel development that some say could spoil the small-town character of the popular wine tourism destination.

As plans emerged that Healdsburg is considering adding a new downtown hotel, a group of residents with a history of fighting development announced in an email its intention to “slow this runaway tourism train.”

The group, Healdsburg Citizens for Sustainable Solutions, may propose a ballot measure to limit hotel development, said co-founder Warren Watkins.

Warren Watkins.

Warren Watkins.

The group takes inspiration from Larry Barnett, the former mayor of Sonoma and former bed-and-breakfast owner who gathered enough signatures to put the question of hotel development to Sonoma voters in November.

Sonoma’s hotel-limitation measure would put a cap on new hotels or expansions involving more than 25 rooms, as long as the hotel occupancy rate remains under 80 percent.

“We support what Sonoma is doing,” Watkins said in an interview. “We think their hotel measure may be a good measure to follow. This is a tipping point. It’s about representing the quality of life for locals.”

A limit on hotels didn’t sit well with some council members, who warned of economic consequences.

Watkins’ group fought the Saggio Hills housing and luxury hotel development at the north edge of Healdsburg. In 2011, the group lost a long legal battle to block the project on environmental grounds, but the project has yet to break ground.

The latest fight centers around plans for a hotel just south of Healdsburg Plaza. The Kessler Collection, a Florida-based hotel company, reportedly has had closed-session meetings with the City Council about building what has been described as a 60- to 70-room, four- to five-story hotel.

The company also has had meetings with Sonoma officials to explore a potential hotel project there, but plans are on hold pending the city’s referendum on hotel development.

The Kessler Collection did not respond to a request for comment on a potential Healdsburg hotel-limitation measure.

A new hotel could generate hundreds of thousands of dollars in transient occupancy taxes, which go into the city’s general fund, Healdsburg Chamber of Commerce officials said. The city has two downtown hotels, The Healdsburg Hotel and h2hotel, as well as a handful of motels, inns and B&Bs. On busy weekends when rooms are full, visitors must stay in neighboring communities.

Chamber Executive Director Carla Howell said she wasn’t sure if Healdsburg needs additional hotel rooms, but doesn’t think a ballot measure to limit hotel growth is appropriate.

“I have concerns about any ballot measure that limits business. Doing something like that would be extremely disruptive to this tight-knit community,” she said.

Opponents of hotel growth say they have not yet committed to pushing a ballot measure and they want to see how the vote goes in Sonoma. Jim Winston, a Healdsburg slow-growth proponent, said limits should be placed on the size of new hotels.

“I think a large hotel is inappropriate, especially for the gateway of the city,” he said. “A 25-room hotel is more in scale with the small-town character of Healdsburg.”

Some council members are not in favor of a blanket limit on hotel development. Mayor Susan Jones said each hotel proposal should be evaluated and decided on individually.

“I don’t want to put a limit or a moratorium on hotels,” Jones said. “At the current time, the hotels we have can’t keep up with demand.”

She added that the council has not seen a specific proposal from The Kessler Collection.

Councilman Gary Plass said a measure to limit hotel growth could be economically crippling.

“What we have to do is continue to supply the tools to support strong economic growth,” he said. “I don’t think a ballot measure would be beneficial to the community.”

You can reach Staff Writer Matt Brown at 521-5206 or matt.brown@pressdemocrat.com.

6 Responses to “Healdsburg group wants hotel crackdown”

  1. bear says:

    Basic economics: oversaturate a market with the same tourist crap and many businesses will fail. Isn’t this oten the end result of “free market capitalism?” Good luck with over-extended public services and vacant buildings.

    Basic democracy: the Healdsburg City Council can do whatever they want without regard for the opinions on this board.

    Thumb up 3 Thumb down 3

  2. Steveguy says:

    Why not a tax paying hotel and the local revenue derived from it ? The SMART Plan is for Section 8 housing for workers to commute to San Rafael, but the problem there is that they plan to build the same in San Rafael for workers to commute to Healdsburg !

    Why have a revenue generating and ancillary spending by the customer plans to interfere with the welfare state ? Why ?

    Why, because Government uses ” FREE ” money while normal citizens have to prove up their plan to the banksters. The Government has their chosen developers, how dare someone come in with a private idea and plan !!!!

    25 rooms ? I say build a 50 room homeless shelter ! That will teach them for investing in a community !

    How dare someone propose a win/win !

    Thumb up 3 Thumb down 1

  3. Lee says:

    Another legal scam to extract $$$ from companies wanting to build hotels in Healdsburg.
    It seems to work, that group never won any significant concessions, yet pocketed hundreds of thousands of dollars.

    Thumb up 9 Thumb down 4

  4. James Bennett says:

    Right on Greg;
    be careful what you wish for, you might get it.

    Unless you like Smart Growth charm.

    Thumb up 7 Thumb down 5

  5. Greg Karraker says:

    Small town charm is often the opposite of charming. When the mayor of Cotati, who is always bleating about small town character, wants to have a nice day, he has publicly admitted he takes his wife to Healdsburg. There’s something about prosperity, cleanliness, and optimism that has a charm of its own. Those in Healdsburg who are nostalgic for poverty and decrepitude, they can always move to Cotati, and enjoy the weeds and empty storefronts they label as small town charm.

    Thumb up 17 Thumb down 5

  6. James Bennett says:

    More ‘advocacy’ (read: lobbying) groups creating faux resistance to free market, automobiles, freedoms, etc..

    Legitimate resistance is ignored or spun to marginalize and discredit.

    If local government sprays Roundup on business, and we stifle tourism?

    What’s left?

    Thumb up 12 Thumb down 3

Leave a Reply