WatchSonoma Watch

Neighbors of Rohnert Park casino want wells monitored


For immediate neighbors of the Indian casino being built on the edge of Rohnert Park, worries about the project’s impacts have been underlined by years of dread that it will drain their wells dry.

Though the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria reduced the scale of its project, and as a result slashed the estimated amount of water it would use — from 106 million gallons a year to 36 million — fears persist.

Project coordinator Kevin Cullinen of the Sotoyome Resource Conservation District removes a sensor from the well of Millbrae Avenue resident Dennis Carrera as he checks the depth to the top of the water’s surface. Behind him, project assistant Kari Wester, far right, goes over the contents of a monitoring and well information binder with resident Dennis Carrera and his neighbor Pat Fabbiani in Rohnert Park on Friday, Jan. 18, 2013. (BETH SCHLANKER / The Press Democrat)

“I’m shaking in my boots,” said Dennis Carrera, a Millbrae Avenue resident who lives about a mile northwest of the casino site, where two wells are to be drilled to 600 feet. That’s deeper than nearly all the 200 wells within a two-mile radius of the casino, according to environmental reports prepared for the project.

In Sacramento last summer, at hearings where legislators reviewed the tribe’s proposed gambling compact with the state, some residents said they feared for their livelihoods.

“If they go dry, we have to leave; we have nowhere to live,” said Selena Polston, who lives on her organic farm about 1½ miles from the fast-rising casino.

Now, Carrera and Polston are among those who have enrolled in a program the federal government required the tribe to set up to monitor well levels within the two-mile radius. Under the program, the tribe will compensate property owners whose wells are affected by the casino, and an adjoining hotel planned for a later date.

“If there are any impacts, this will help the property owner justify any claims,” said Jay Jasperse, chief engineer for the Sonoma County Water Agency.

On Friday, two staff members of the Sotoyome Resource Conservation District, which the tribe has hired to run the testing aspect of the program, used a sonic meter and an electronic tape measure fitted with a sensor to check the water level in Carrera’s well.

Kevin Cullinen, a Sotoyome project cordinator, told Carrera and another neighbor, Pat Fabbiani, that the program would run for up to three years after the casino starts pumping its well. That is expected to happen near the end of the year when the casino is projected to open its doors.

“I think it’s a good thing but I don’t think it’s going to help us,” said Fabbiani, whose initial well test is next week. She said the hotel is her real concern because it will create the heaviest water demand. The monitoring program should be extended to take into full account its impact on surrounding wells, she said.

“We want five to 10 years of monitoring,” Fabbiani said.

She and Carrera are among more than 70 people to have so far enrolled in the program.

“Generally, the feedback has been very positive,” said Kara Heckert, executive director of the Sotoyome district, a non-regulatory public agency that works with private landowners on water and conservation issues.

“I am very pleased about it,” said Ken Yonts, who lives on Millbrae Avenue resident about a mile from the casino.

“I think if it didn’t happen I would probably have to have gone and paid for it,” he said, “because I think it’s critical to have a baseline, because later if something goes wrong, what would you do?”

The tribe is paying the Sotoyome district $126,035 to manage the program.

District employees are to make quarterly site visits to check variations from the baseline established during the first measurement. And property owners keep a log book to record well performance and related issues.

If wells become unusable within three years of when the Graton Rancheria starts pumping from its casino well, the tribe is to pay property-owners part of the cost of replacing, rehabilitating or deepening their wells, according to the federal requirements.

A civil engineer hired by the tribe will determine whether there has been an impact and its extent.

“That’s his job; we’re just collecting the data for you guys,” Cullinen told Fabbiani and Carrera.

Carrera is among neighbors uncomfortable with that process, saying they long have been excluded from decisions involving the casino.

“There’s been a lot of promises,” he said. “I don’t have the confidence that if my well goes dry, that they’re going to bail me out.” He called the program a “band-aid.”

But it has assuaged other residents’ fears. They say it will make it easier to reach agreement with the tribe for compensation.

“Without it, if someone comes in a year from now, two years from now, and they claim a problem, it’s going to be a fight,” said Dietrich Stroeh, who lives on Wilfred Avenue, the north border of the Graton tribe’s reservation.

Stroeh, a former general manager of the Marin Municipal Water District, helped design the monitoring program, working with the county water agency, tribal representatives and Sotoyome district officials.

“Most of the wells out there are … pretty shallow. They could very well be affected,” Stroeh said. “This way, there’s at least be some legitimate” data.

On Bartleson Road, toward the edge of the two-mile radius, Polston and her husband, Steve Schwartz came away encouraged from their first encounter with the program.

“I think it’s pretty positive. With the (Sotoyome district), that gives a level of independence in regards to the monitoring role,” said Schwartz.

“I think this lays a foundation for protecting us long-term,” he said.

Others, like Fabbiani, say that if the impacts are severe enough, no compensation will be enough.

“If there’s no water, what do you compensate?,” she said. “Even if you move, your property is valueless.”

Information about the program appears to have spread unevenly. Down the street from Carrera, Stephanie Duncan said she was not signed up because she hadn’t learned about it and she wasn’t sure she would participate.

“I haven’t gotten anything in the mail from the tribe, nothing,” she said. “It depends on who’s paying for it. I can’t; I’m on a fixed income.”

The program is free of charge. Data about water use is not collected by the district or the tribe, but is retained by property owners, Heckert said.

“We’re providing a technical education and outreach service is how we see it,” she said.

Separately, the tribe is going to pay the county $1.5 million toward a project to analyze and conserve groundwater use. It will also, starting at about the fourth year after the casino opens, make annual payments of $275,000 to operate that program. Those payments were negotiated by the county with the tribe in an agreement to offset casino impacts.

The federal government also required the tribe to start a separate program to monitor groundwater levels and quality at 12 wells, conducting monthly testing for at least four years.

Representatives of the Graton Rancheria did not respond to requests for comment for this story.

(You can reach Staff Writer Jeremy Hay at 521-5212 or jeremy.hay@pressdemocrat.com or on Twitter @jeremyhay)

7 Responses to “Neighbors of Rohnert Park casino want wells monitored”

  1. Elephant says:

    Bear and others –

    The wells you speak of tap into what is called the Russian River Aquifer. It is recharged primarily by the Russian River itself (through the gravel that Syar and others mine from the river and its banks) and secondarily through rainfall. As the soil in Rohnert Park is adobe clay, very little rainfall makes its way to the aquifer.

    The City of Rohnert Park has its own wells tapping into the RR aquifer. They have pulled out so much water without it getting recharged that many private well owners in the area (especially at the edges of the aquifer in Penngrove) have had to drill their wells deeper to remain functional. I have heard that this has led to the entire Rohnert Park area sinking. After all, each year, new areas flood that never did before. The casino pulling more water out of the aquifer spells disaster for their neighbors and their private wells.

    There is a pipeline that carries water south to Petaluma and North Marin. Yes we supply water to Marin. This pipeline was put in 60+ years ago with a 50-year lifetime. Can you say oops?

    Also a few years ago, the state ordered the Sonoma County Water Agency to reduce their water “take” by 20%. As we currently stand, Sonoma County has at least 30% more development than the SCWA can supply water.

    Whether the water comes from the SCWA or wells that tap into the same source, Sonoma County has a serious water supply problem. Too bad that you’ll never read about it in the PD as people they helped put into office made it happen.

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  2. bear says:

    Dear Friends,

    There are two sources of water in Sonoma County. Groundwater (wells) and the Russian River water system.

    The Russian River will be out of water by 2020.

    Figure it out.

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 6

  3. Steveguy says:

    Why does it have to be Rodent Park water ? The pipe to Marin is nearby.

    They make rules that confound common sense, but perpetuate many consultants and management positions that cost MILLIONS.

    The SMART Train should stop at the Casino. oh my

    Thumb up 3 Thumb down 3

  4. Reality Check says:


    Yes, RP will give them a sewage hookup. The stated reason was they feared an enviro consequence too terrible to do otherwise, and that it would directly affect RP. I guess the city doesn’t feel the same toward some landowners in the unincorporated area.

    Thumb up 4 Thumb down 2

  5. David says:

    @Reality Check

    They are hooking up to RP City sewer, how is water any different? The tribe and the Las Vegas mob own the RP City Counsel, lock stock and barrel.

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 3

  6. Reality Check says:

    Home Depot and Walmart are within city limits and draw from Rohnert Park’s water service. A condition of accessing city water is being within the city and subject to its laws and regulations. That is not something a tribe could do and maintain its fiction of sovereignty.

    If we’ve strayed from common sense it’s in pretending that we can drop islands of faux sovereignty into communities and not have these kinds of problems.

    Thumb up 10 Thumb down 1

  7. Steveguy says:

    Can’t they hook up with County Water ? Or at least partial ?

    I have a close friend down the road, she got the notice and chose not to bother as she is farther away. I don’t think that she will be effected as it is lowland and has good percolation in that area of Stony Point Road.

    In these ‘modern times’, it seems that we have strayed from real common sense. I see no common sense here, just some ‘regulations’ and temporary so called solutions.

    What happens when someone’s well runs dry after the 3 years ? Does Home Depot and Walmart nearby run wells too ? Why can’t they use county water as a portion ?

    Never mind, common sense doesn’t matter anymore. Oh my

    Thumb up 6 Thumb down 4

Leave a Reply